Personal Client Services
Personal Insurance Policyholder Service Center Phone Numbers
Cumberland Mutal 1-800-232-6992
Franklin Mutual 1-973-948-8800
Hanover 1-855-221-7652
Plymouth Rock 1-833-511-7625
Progressive 1-877-776-2436
Travelers 1-877-872-8737
Personal Insurance Policy Payments
Andover/Merrimack- www.andovercos.com
Cumberland Mutal – https://www.cumberlandmutual.com/make-a-payment
Farmers – www.FarmersofSalem.com
Hagerty – https://login.hagerty.com/TemporaryAccess?purpose=PayBill
FMI – www.FMIWEB.com
Foremost – www.foremostpayonline.com
Hanover – www.myhanoverpolicy.com
Met Life – www.eservice.metlife.com
Narragansett Bay (NBIC )- https://www.nbic.com/make-payment/
NJ Skylands – www.NJSI.com
Philadelphia Contributionship – www.contributionship.com
Plymouth Rock Assurance – https://www.plymouthrock.com
24 Hours Payment Phone# 877-266-6659
Progressive – www.progressiveagent.com
Stillwater – https://stillwaterinsurance.com/SelfService/main/login
Swyfft Pay Online – https://www.swyfft.com/MakeAPayment
Travelers – www.mytravelers.com
Personal Insurance Claims
American Modern Insurance Company 1-800-375-2075
Andover Insurance Companies (Whelan Adjustment) 1-908-289-7377
Cumberland Mutal – https://www.cumberlandmutual.com/report-a-claim-3
Farmers of Salem 1-800-498-0954
Fidelity Flood 1-800-725-9472
Foremost Insurance Company 1-800-527-3907
Franklin Mutual Insurance Company/FMI 1-800-842-0551 (press option 2)
Hagerty 1-800-385-0274
Hanover Insurance Group 1-800-628-0250
Harleysville Flood Insurance Company 1-800-759-8656
Narragansett Bay (NBIC) Claims 1- 800-343-3375
NJ Skylands 1-866-279-7688
Philadelphia Contributionship 1-800-269-1409
Plymouth Rock Assurance 1-833-511-7625 – pracclaimscontact@prac.com
Progressive Insurance Company 1-800-776-2778
Stillwater Insurance 1-800-220-1351
Swyfft 1-855-479-9338
Travelers Flood 1-800-505-0193
Travelers of New Jersey 1-800-238-6225