Personal Client Services

Personal Insurance Policyholder Service Center Phone Numbers

American Commerce Insurance Company 1-844-509-4653

Franklin Mutual 1-973-948-8800

Hanover 1-855-221-7652

Plymouth Rock 1-866-669-6439

Progressive 1-877-776-2436

Travelers 1-877-872-8737


Personal Insurance Policy Payments

Andover/Merrimack- www.andovercos.com

Farmers – www.FarmersofSalem.com

Hagerty – https://login.hagerty.com/TemporaryAccess?purpose=PayBill

FMI – www.FMIWEB.com

Foremost – www.foremostpayonline.com

Hanover – www.myhanoverpolicy.com

Met Life – www.eservice.metlife.com

Narragansett Bay (NBIC )- https://www.nbic.com/make-payment/

NJ Skylands – www.NJSI.com

Philadelphia Contributionship – www.contributionship.com

Plymouth Rock Assurance – https://www.plymouthrock.com
24 Hours Payment Phone# 877-266-6659

Progressive – www.progressiveagent.com

Stillwater – https://stillwaterinsurance.com/SelfService/main/login

Swyfft Pay Online – https://www.swyfft.com/MakeAPayment

Travelers – www.mytravelers.com


Personal Insurance Claims

American Commerce 1-877-224-5677

American Modern Insurance Company 1-800-375-2075

Andover Insurance Companies (Whelan Adjustment) 1-908-289-7377

Farmers of Salem 1-800-498-0954

Fidelity Flood 1-800-725-9472

Foremost Insurance Company 1-800-527-3907

Franklin Mutual Insurance Company/FMI 1-800-842-0551 (press option 2)

Hagerty 1-800-385-0274

Hanover Insurance Group 1-800-628-0250

Harleysville Flood Insurance Company 1-800-759-8656

Narragansett Bay (NBIC) Claims 1- 800-343-3375

NJ Skylands 1-866-279-7688

Philadelphia Contributionship 1-800-269-1409

Plymouth Rock Assurance 1-888-725-9006 – https://efnol.plymouthrock.com/

Progressive Insurance Company 1-800-776-2778

Stillwater Insurance 1-800-220-1351

Swyfft 1-855-479-9338

Travelers Flood 1-800-505-0193

Travelers of New Jersey 1-800-238-6225


Online Payments for Agency Billed Policies

V-check https://www.securevcheck.com/?id=icnj